Debentures are fixed-income instruments issued by corporations to raise capital. They are broadly categorized into Convertible Debentures (CDs), which can convert into equity shares over time, and Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs), which remain strictly debt instruments offering higher regular interest payouts.
This article breaks down the differences between convertible debentures and non-convertible debentures (NCDs) and how each is structured.
Key Takeaways
- Convertible debentures can be converted into the issuing company’s equity shares after a specified period, while non-convertible debentures (NCDs) remain debt instruments until maturity and are never converted.
- NCDs offer higher fixed interest rates than convertible debentures, compensating investors for giving up the potential upside of equity conversion.
- Secured NCDs, backed by the issuer’s assets, carry lower risk than unsecured NCDs, which rely solely on the company’s creditworthiness.
In India, both instrument types fall under SEBI’s Issue and Listing of Non-Convertible Securities (ILNCS) Regulations, 2021, and convertible securities also draw on SEBI’s ICDR framework for the equity-conversion component.
Tax treatment differs meaningfully: NCD interest is taxed as regular income with TDS now applicable even on Demat-held listed NCDs, while converting a convertible debenture into shares is not treated as a taxable transfer at the time of conversion.
What is a Debenture?
A debenture is a debt instrument issued by a company to raise capital from investors, promising a fixed interest rate (coupon) over a defined tenure, with the principal repaid at maturity. Debentures are unsecured by default under the Companies Act framework. Issuers frequently choose to back them with specific assets to reassure investors, at which point the “secured” classification applies.
What are Convertible Debentures (CDs)?
Convertible debentures act as hybrid financial instruments. They begin their lifecycle as standard debt, paying regular interest to the holder. After a predetermined date or milestone, the investor has the right, or is obligated, to convert those debentures into a fixed number of the company's equity shares.
- Fully Convertible Debentures (FCDs): The entire face value is automatically converted into equity shares upon maturity.
- Partly Convertible Debentures (PCDs): Only a portion of the debenture converts to equity, while the remainder stays as a fixed-income debt instrument.
Also Read About: Why Do Companies Issue Convertible Debentures?
What are Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs)?
NCDs cannot be converted into stock. That’s because investors give up any claim to future equity upside; issuing companies sweeten the deal by offering significantly higher coupon rates compared to standard bank fixed deposits or convertible instruments.
- Secured NCDs: Backed by the company's tangible assets (like machinery, real estate, or receivables). If the company is in financial distress, these assets are liquidated to repay investors first.
- Unsecured NCDs: Not backed by physical collateral, carrying a higher risk profile and therefore offering even higher interest rates to offset that risk.
Also Read About: How to Buy NCD?
Example of NCD Coupon Rate vs. Effective Yield
Scenario: If an NCD with a face value of ₹1,000 offers an 8% annual coupon, the investor receives ₹80 in cash interest per year regardless of the market price.
Yield Calculation: If that same NCD is purchased at a discounted market price of ₹950 on the secondary exchange, the effective yield increases to 8.42% (calculated as ₹80 ÷ ₹950), providing a higher return for investors buying below par.
The Difference Between Convertible and Non-Convertible Debentures
|
Feature |
Convertible Debenture |
Non-Convertible Debenture (NCD) |
|
Conversion into equity |
Yes, after a specified period or event, as per the offer terms |
No, remains a debt instrument until maturity |
|
Interest rate |
Lower, since conversion optionality adds value |
Higher, to compensate for no conversion upside |
|
Investor profile |
Growth-oriented investors seeking some equity upside with downside protection |
Income-focused investors prioritising stable, predictable returns |
|
Impact on company’s equity base |
Dilutes existing shareholders upon conversion |
No dilution. Remains a balance-sheet liability until repaid |
|
Risk-return profile |
Lower fixed income, potential capital appreciation if the stock performs well |
Fixed, higher income, but no equity-linked upside |
Types of Convertible Debentures
|
Type |
Description |
|
Fully Convertible Debenture (FCD) |
The entire debenture amount is converted into equity shares as per the pre-agreed terms |
|
Partly Convertible Debenture (PCD) |
Only a portion of the debenture converts into equity, while the remainder is redeemed as debt |
|
Optionally Convertible Debenture (OCD) |
The investor has the choice, not the obligation, to convert into equity within a specified window |
Types of Non-Convertible Debentures
|
Type |
Description |
|
Secured NCD |
Backed by the issuer’s assets or collateral, offering recourse if the company defaults |
|
Unsecured NCD |
Not backed by specific assets. Investors rely solely on the issuer’s creditworthiness, and earn a higher coupon for this added risk |
|
Redeemable NCD |
Repaid in full at a specified maturity date (the vast majority of listed NCDs fall into this category) |
How Conversion Works: A Simple Illustration
Number of Shares on Conversion = Debenture Face Value ÷ Conversion Price
Example: An investor holds a fully convertible debenture with a face value of ₹1,000, and the terms specify a conversion price of ₹100 per share.
Number of Shares = ₹1,000 ÷ ₹100 = 10 equity shares
If the company’s share price rises well above the conversion price by the conversion date, the investor benefits from the equity upside. If the share price falls below it, the investor still receives shares on the pre-agreed terms, which may be less attractive than simply holding an NCD to maturity.
Risk and Return: A Side-by-Side View
|
Factor |
Convertible Debenture |
Non-Convertible Debenture |
|
Credit risk |
Present, though partially offset by equity upside potential |
Present. Central to evaluating any NCD, mitigated by secured structures |
|
Interest rate risk |
Lower impact, since equity potential can offset rate movements |
More directly affected by prevailing interest rate changes |
|
Liquidity |
Depends on listing status and trading volumes |
Depends on listing status. Many retail NCDs are listed on NSE/BSE debt segments |
|
Credit rating relevance |
Still relevant, but equity upside is a key consideration too |
Central factor — always check the rating from CRISIL, ICRA, or CARE before investing |
SEBI’s Regulatory Framework for Convertible and Non-convertible Debentures
Both convertible and non-convertible debentures are governed primarily by the SEBI (Issue and Listing of Non-Convertible Securities) Regulations, 2021 (ILNCS Regulations), which consolidated and replaced the earlier separate regulations for non-convertible debentures and securitized debt instruments.
Key Regulatory Points Include:
- Mandatory credit rating: Public issues of NCDs require a credit rating from a SEBI-registered rating agency, which must be disclosed in the offer document.
- Disclosure requirements: Issuers must disclose the terms of conversion (for convertible debentures), security details (for secured NCDs), and use of proceeds in the prospectus.
- Debenture trustee requirement: A SEBI-registered debenture trustee must be appointed to safeguard investor interests and monitor compliance with the terms of the issue, particularly asset cover for secured NCDs.
- Convertible securities and ICDR overlap: Because the equity-conversion component effectively becomes a share issuance, convertible debentures also draw on provisions under SEBI’s ICDR Regulations governing the pricing and disclosure of the equity to be issued on conversion.
Tax Treatment for Convertible and Non-convertible Debentures
Tax treatment differs at two stages: while the interest income is being earned, and when the instrument is sold, redeemed, or converted.
|
Aspect |
Non-Convertible Debentures |
Convertible Debentures |
|
Interest income |
Taxed as “Income from Other Sources” at the investor’s applicable slab rate |
Same treatment on the interest portion earned before conversion |
|
TDS on interest |
10% TDS under Section 193 if interest exceeds ₹10,000 in a financial year — this now applies even to listed NCDs held in Demat form, following the removal of the earlier exemption by the Finance Act, 2023. 20% TDS if PAN is not furnished |
Same TDS rule applies to the interest-paying period before conversion |
|
Sale before maturity (STCG) |
Held 12 months or less: gains taxed at the investor’s slab rate |
Same rule applies if the debenture (before conversion) is sold within 12 months |
|
Sale before maturity (LTCG) |
Held over 12 months: taxed at 12.5% without indexation |
Same rule applies if the debenture is sold, rather than converted, after 12 months |
|
Conversion into equity |
Not applicable |
Conversion itself is not treated as a “transfer” under Section 47(x) of the Income Tax Act, so no capital gains tax arises at the point of conversion |
|
Holding period after conversion |
Not applicable |
The holding period for the resulting equity shares is computed from the original date of debenture allotment, not the conversion date, which matters for determining later STCG/LTCG treatment on the shares |
|
TDS relief |
Can be avoided by submitting Form 15G/15H if eligible, or claimed as a credit while filing ITR |
Same relief options apply on the debenture’s interest component |
Example of TDS Threshold Calculation
-
Scenario: If you earn ₹12,000 in total interest across a financial year from a listed NCD held in your Demat account, you have crossed the statutory ₹10,000 threshold set under Section 193 of the Income Tax Act.
-
Tax Deduction: The issuer or intermediary will deduct a 10% TDS (₹1,200) on the entire ₹12,000 payout (or on the amount exceeding the limit depending on current operational interpretations, though typically triggered once the aggregate interest crosses the limit), which can later be claimed as a tax credit when filing your Income Tax Return (ITR).
Conclusion
The choice between a convertible and a non-convertible debenture ultimately comes down to what an investor values more: the predictability of a fixed return, or the possibility of participating in a company’s equity growth later. NCDs suit investors who want stable, contractually fixed income and are comfortable evaluating credit risk directly. In contrast, convertible debentures suit those willing to accept a lower initial yield for the option of upside if the issuer’s stock performs well.
